top of page
Men in Suits
  • Directors' Institute

The Shift in India Inc.: Quality Over Quantity in the Quest for Independent Directors

As we approach 2024, India Inc. is set to witness an interesting phenomenon. Over 800 independent directors are due to mandatorily retire, and there is an increased emphasis on the recruitment of qualified individuals to fill these crucial positions. A pressing question, though, is whether India, a country with a population surpassing a billion, is facing a talent crunch for Independent Directors. It’s essential to focus on the ironical situation that exists; a country teeming with potential talents might be running out of quality candidates for this significant role.

Independent Directors

The Convergence of Requirement and Value Addition from Independent Directors


The proficiency test for Independent Directors entails a comprehensive understanding of corporate laws and regulations, attributing to the weighty responsibility they shoulder. Independent Directors are no longer seen merely as statutory requirements; their role extends to much broader aspects of corporate governance.


Independent Directors: Guardians of Corporate Success

Independent Directors bring to the table their unique skillsets and experiences, fortifying the organization's internal control environment. They provide a counterbalance to potential management weaknesses, helping ensure legal and ethical practices, and strengthening accounting controls. This promotes transparency and decision-making that considers the wider organization's interests and its stakeholders.


In India, where many corporations are family-run, Independent Directors historically have often been connected to the Promoter or Chairman. However, with an increasing focus on global expansion and the need for expert guidance, there has been a paradigm shift towards hiring competent Independent Directors. Recent trends highlight this significant shift.


The Empirical Evidence: A Shift Towards Qualified Independent Directors

A report published by Excellence Enablers indicates an upswing in the trend towards hiring independent directors based on their qualifications and capabilities. Most firms out of the Nifty 100 companies have complied with the requirement for hiring independent directors over the past year. This shift towards hiring qualified independent directors augments the corporate governance standards in India, paving the way for expert guidance, diverse viewpoints, and healthy skepticism in boardrooms.


Independent Directors: Flagbearers of Corporate Progress


Boardrooms often present challenging environments where conflicting opinions emerge. Independent Directors, with their considerable experience and expertise, play a critical role in resolving such conflicts objectively. Their independent perspectives facilitate resolutions benefiting all stakeholders. As such, the recent trend involves the onboarding of professionals like lawyers, bankers, risk professionals, and financial experts as Independent Directors.


The quest for corporate growth calls for meticulous planning and precise execution of business strategies. Independent Directors often provide the necessary visionary leadership needed to establish objectives and formulate strategies aligning with the company's overall mission.


Quality vs. Quantity: The Final Verdict


As the maximum term of 10 years for Independent Directors nears its end, the demand for such roles has escalated. Independence, however, should not merely be a tick-box exercise; it's a state of mind, and without a commitment to adhere to corporate governance principles, the composition alone does not guarantee effective boards.


Choosing Independent Directors based purely on visibility, market perception, or relationships with the promoters is inadequate. In today's world of increased scrutiny, Independent Directors serve as a catalyst for improved communication between the executive team and the shareholders. The entire process through which Independent Directors are identified, nominated, and recruited needs careful introspection. The challenge lies in developing a search strategy focusing on quality over quantity. This move from quantity to quality may indeed bring about a transformative shift in the corporate governance landscape of India. After all, in the absence of true independence, the value derived by stakeholders from a company may be inversely proportional to the number of seats on the board.


In conclusion, as India Inc. prepares for a mass retirement of Independent Directors in 2024, the focus must be on quality over quantity. The search for Independent Directors should transcend beyond numbers, focusing on skills pertinent to the current and emerging business requirements. As the guardians of corporate governance, Independent Directors are the catalysts for change, propelling companies towards sustainable success in an ever-evolving global business environment.


Our Directors’ Institute- World Council of Directors can help you accelerate your board journey by training you on your roles and responsibilities to be carried out in an efficient manner helping you to make a significant contribution to the board and raise corporate governance standards within the organization.


Our ESG Expert certification will help you to amplify your understanding of corporate governance in a detailed manner paving the way for you to become a globally recognized ESG leader.

17 views0 comments
bottom of page