.png)
Corporate Governance is transforming in an era of rapid technological advancements, shifting social norms and market dynamics. The traditional boardroom, often seen as the bastion of seasoned executives and established industry veterans, is now facing a new wave of change: the integration of younger professionals. This shift represents a profound opportunity to invigorate boardrooms with fresh perspectives, innovative thinking, and a dynamic approach to strategic decision-making.
With their unique vantage points shaped by the digital age, global connectivity, and a heightened awareness of social and environmental issues, young directors are poised to offer invaluable contributions to corporate boards. Their familiarity with emerging technologies, trends in consumer behaviour, and new forms of communication can drive modernisation and enhance a company's ability to stay competitive in a rapidly evolving landscape. Infusing youthful energy and new ideas can catalyse innovation, fostering a culture of agility and forward-thinking.
However, this integration has its challenges. Introducing younger professionals into established boards can disrupt long-standing traditions and hierarchies, leading to potential friction with veteran members who may be accustomed to a particular way of operating. The generational gap in experiences, expectations, and management styles can create tensions that must be navigated carefully. Moreover, the effectiveness of younger directors hinges on their ability to balance their fresh perspectives with the wisdom and strategic insight that come with experience.
Therefore, the debate around board composition is about generational diversity and finding the right balance between experience and innovation. It is about understanding how young directors can complement and enhance the existing board dynamics while addressing the inherent risks and challenges accompanying such integration.
This discourse on board composition and the role of young directors explores the multifaceted benefits and challenges of integrating younger professionals into corporate boards. By delving into how youthful insights can drive strategic advantage and how to manage the complexities of this transition, we can uncover pathways to build more resilient, innovative, and forward-looking governance structures. In this journey, the convergence of age and experience with fresh perspectives promises to redefine the Corporate Governance landscape, paving the way for a more inclusive and dynamic future.
What is the composition of a board?
The composition of an organisation's board of directors or governing body means the constitution and characteristics of the individuals who serve on it. The board of directors is composed of the following members:
Dimensions. An adequate number of directors should supervise your organisation's nominating and governance committee, audit committee, and other board subdivisions.
Qualifications and experience. The business should be managed professionally by board directors with expertise in finance, investing, management, and other relevant fields.
Diverse. Companies must have at least two diverse board members to satisfy the Securities and Exchange Commission's rules.
The influence of board talents on business performance
A well-organised board of directors substantially enhances the performance of a company. The board's ability to address skills deficits is positively impacted by the number of skills it possesses, which is advantageous for overall business performance and risk management.
Nevertheless, research indicates that the maxim "the more, the better" does not apply to all business models and contexts. Therefore, we should investigate how the qualifications and experiences of board directors influence the business's performance.
The board's ability sets
The University of Melbourne investigated the influence of board skills on business performance. It assessed the skill sets of the boards and issued the subsequent findings: Nine abilities are present on most boards. The most prevalent talents on U.S. corporate boards include finance, company business, management, leadership, international, outside executive, strategic planning, governance and technology.
A company's board of directors is responsible for guiding it forward while retaining appropriate oversight. The board must find the right balance in handling issues while still fulfilling its obligations to its employees, business associates, and the general public. The boardroom benefits greatly from having various perspectives to fulfil its main objective of creating value.
In light of this, PwC's Annual Corporate Directors Survey includes a Board variety component that asks directors to evaluate some factors, including tenure, gender, and ethnicity, and to determine how much each adds to the variety of thought. This year's study asks about the importance of age diversity among board members for the first time, and the replies from current directors were impressive.
Comparable to the replies on gender and tenure, around 90% of directors stated that age diversity was "very" or "somewhat" necessary to achieving thinking diversity. Although these numbers show the current trends in board recruitment, it takes time to imagine them, even two or three years ago.
There is no denying that board diversity has recently gained popularity. However, the term "board diversity" is often used to refer to the presence of women and persons of diverse backgrounds on boards, regardless of their age.
Duties of the Board
The board of directors is accountable for a diverse array of responsibilities that are essential to a company's overall health and prosperity. These obligations encompass establishing the organisation's overarching strategy, selecting and assessing the CEO's performance, and guaranteeing adherence to applicable laws and regulations.
The board of directors is responsible for establishing the company's overarching strategy. This encompasses developing a vision and mission statement, identifying long-term goals and objectives, and developing a strategy to achieve them. For instance, the board of directors of a company may elect to pursue a new product line, invest in new technology, or expand into new markets.
The board of directors also evaluates and selects the CEO's performance. This encompasses recruiting and employing a CEO, monitoring their performance, and determining compensation. The board of directors is also essential in succession planning, as it ensures the company has a plan if the current CEO retires or departs.
The board of directors is also responsible for guaranteeing that the company adheres to all pertinent laws and regulations. This encompasses ensuring that the company's financial statements are precise and comply with all relevant accounting standards. The board of directors is also instrumental in managing risk and maintaining the company's financial stability.
The board of directors is responsible for the company's performance and is involved in decision-making processes that impact the shareholders. Critical decisions, including the election of board members, the ratification of significant transactions, and any modifications to the company's bylaws, can be voted on by shareholders. Additionally, shareholders are entitled to receive financial statements and other pertinent information regarding the organisation and participate in and address the annual meeting. For instance, the board of directors would be accountable for assessing a substantial acquisition's potential risks and benefits and providing a recommendation to the shareholders. The shareholders would subsequently be granted the opportunity to vote on the proposal, and the board of directors would be obligated to evaluate the vote results.
The board of directors significantly influences the Corporate Governance process. They are accountable for various responsibilities essential to a company's overall health and prosperity, including establishing its overall strategy, selecting and evaluating the CEO, and assuring compliance with laws and regulations. They are responsible to the company's shareholders, who can vote on significant decisions and receive financial statements and other company information. The board is responsible for ensuring that the company is well-governed and that its strategy, management, and compliance with laws align with its goals and objectives.
Best practices for the composition of four boards
According to extensive corporate research conducted over the years, evaluate the optimal board composition:
1. Limiting the size of boards
Korn Ferry reports that Russell 3,000 companies have an average of nine board directors, while S&P companies have 12. The United Kingdom, Italy, and Spain are among the countries where the board size typically ranges from 10 to 11 members. Nevertheless, Joseph E. Griesedieck, Vice Chairman at Korn Ferry, contends that board directors should be increased for optimal board governance. Increased board sizes result in more excellent perspectives and discrepancies in decision-making between internal and external directors. Charles Elson, director of the Corporate Governance Centre at the University of Delaware, suggests that corporations should reduce their boards to seven or ten members.
C-suite administrators find it simpler to communicate with fewer board directors. The most critical factor is that a board committee can be effectively supervised by a group of seven to ten individuals.
2. Consistently updating forums
According to PWC's 2023 board efficacy survey, shareholder communications are overseen by only 57% of board directors. Furthermore, over 89% of directors are interested in replacing at least one board member, while 41% are adamant about replacing at least two.
This survey suggests that the board's composition must be assessed to manage operations and address evolving challenges effectively. Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) also deems the average board tenure of 9 years excessive.
Therefore, PWC suggests the subsequent board refreshment practices for corporate boards:
Establish an attrition action program and replace individual directors every five years.
Establish a maximum board tenure of 9-12 years.
Conduct a consistent evaluation of the board.
3. Prioritising cybersecurity
Forbes predicts that the global cost of cybercrime will exceed $8 trillion by the end of 2023 and $10.5 trillion by 2025. As of 2022, 83% of companies had encountered one or more data breaches.
In the interim, board directors require pertinent cybersecurity expertise, even though cybersecurity is a priority for 70% of boards. In 2022, cybersecurity specialists occupied only 14% of company board seats, a 3% decrease from 2021.
If your board comprises ten directors, at least two or three must possess substantial cybersecurity experience within the IT governance board.
4. Encouraging demographic diversity
Today, a business's diversity significantly enhances its board's efficacy. Nevertheless, the age component of a diverse board is frequently disregarded by boards.
The average age of a board director is 63. Nevertheless, a recent PWC onboard age diversity study revealed that organisations with younger board directors exhibit higher profitability and adaptation metrics.
In the contemporary world, age diversity contributes to a well-rounded combination of innovation, problem-solving, experience, and abilities. It provides companies with diverse boards with an advantage of up to €51.8 billion.
The investigation has also determined that effective boards should have directors between the ages of 30 and 75 to achieve the highest level of age diversity.
The impact of the millennial generation
The millennial generation, around 25 to 40, is the largest demographic group and boards have to deal with its influence. They're not sure if they're prepared, though. Studies show that millennials differ significantly from older generations in terms of their aspirations, communication styles, future vision, and shopping habits.
Nonetheless, as millennials approach their prime years of purchasing and earning, businesses need to be ready to adjust. While the company may not "understand millennials," having a younger person on the board can help bridge the gap.
The value of a diverse age range at executive meetings
Boards have traditionally maintained that age is the only factor in relevant knowledge. However, this presumption is now false. The increasing complexity of digitalisation is changing many aspects of our everyday lives and how our economy and society are organised. This requires new kinds of expertise and modifies the way businesses make decisions.
This has made it easier for businesses to recognise the benefits of having younger, more relatable board members. Today, a sizable portion of the global population is under 30 and resides in developing or emerging countries. They make up the global market for some suppliers and businesses expanding the fastest.
The financial case for racial and gender diversity on boards is becoming increasingly accepted by executives. Even though over half of the world's population is under 30, age diversity has yet to garner the same attention.
It is time for boards' nomination and elections committees to abandon the custom of looking for candidates who have served on boards before. Instead, a range of techniques must be employed to identify talent.
Why is it looking to add youth to the board of directors?
As businesses begin to recognise the benefits of cross-generational workforces and diversity, hiring millennials can also give them a modern perspective on how their decisions will affect all stakeholders, from suppliers and customers to employees and the community.
Younger board members share concerns and ideas that should be discussed more at the boardroom table. Nevertheless, more than adding new directors is required. To set people up for success, boards must also combine onboarding, integration, and a polite, open-minded attitude toward their contributions.
A novel kind of board is about to surface.
Directors with a lengthy service history who specialise in risk and governance will collaborate with younger people chosen for their exceptional topic expertise or practical experience in transformative settings. Nevertheless, their tenure will probably be shorter than the mean of the present.
However, boards that wish to stay ahead of the game should consider appointing at least one next-generation director for their subject matter expertise and their capacity to bring fresh perspectives to the table. If next-generation directors are supported by an accepting board chair and other directors, they can make a long-lasting difference in the board's efficacy during the transition.
The following encourages support for welcoming younger people to the board:
A wide variety of perspectives is necessary for effective Corporate Governance on the board. Diverse viewpoints facilitate more informed decision-making, and a board of directors must consider the opinions of all possible stakeholders.
Boards must be able to draw from a broad spectrum of experience to tackle complex challenges. Diverse viewpoints are advantageous in this age of ever-more complex technical advancement. When competing viewpoints are discussed, the best decisions are made.
Initiatives for racial and gender diversity on boards are currently being developed. However, during the past ten years, a greater understanding of the perils of homogeneity has led to a rise in diversity in boardrooms. A further aspect of diversity is the appointment of younger board members.
Boards become increasingly grateful for a more extensive range of perspectives as they gain experience managing greater diversity.
It should be noted that while several female directors who participated in the study admitted that gender had a role in their first nominations for directorships, they did not think this influence persisted over time.
Corporate Governance and diversity's significance
Corporate Governance refers to the processes that enable stakeholders to safeguard their interests and exert control over operational management. Many parties include government agencies, suppliers, customers, workers, equity shareholders, and creditors. The senior executive team is responsible for formulating and carrying out the company's major operational decisions.
An essential part of corporate governance is the board of directors, which represents shareholders' interests by supervising executive leadership. The extensive stock distribution in public companies makes the directors' service on behalf of shareholders crucial. A board's independence, size, and makeup—including the diversity of its membership—are vital considerations for assessing how well it is carrying out its duties. As such, assisting in developing and directing the business's long-term strategic posture within its industry is a crucial board duty. One could argue that the makeup of the board of directors is essential to its efficacy because resolving strategic difficulties requires various skills and viewpoints. Progressive boards understand this and that their ideal membership reflects the business's strategic aims and the diversity of its stakeholders. Boards increasingly realise that having members with diverse backgrounds, ages, and experiences encourages productive discussion and decision-making. For instance, during the six years ending in 2011, companies with female representation outperformed those without any female board members in terms of average growth, return on equity, and share price performance, according to the 2012 Credit Suisse Research Institute report Gender Diversity and Corporate Performance (Gender diversity and corporate performance, 2012).
Several layers of analysis can be used to examine gender diversity on boards of directors, including individual, firm, industry, and board-level studies. For instance, a female director on a board of directors can act as an example for others. Gender diversity can impact corporate monitoring and organisational legitimacy at the firm level.
Surprisingly enough, there are not many peer-reviewed empirical studies discussing the issue of getting more women on company boards. However, it is noteworthy that some of the available research results show a strong correlation between innovation effectiveness as measured by R&D expenditures and citations and boards with female directors, particularly in industries where creativity and innovation are crucial.
When people talk about the diversity of their boards of directors, they frequently bring up issues of gender, race, and freedom from internal influences within the company. The main thrust of the argument in support of a diverse board is to pick members based on more than just whether they meet one of these criteria. A diversified composition is necessary to encourage diverse perspectives, a prerequisite for productive board discussions. According to Leszczyńska (2018), choosing directors only based on fitting a specific category to achieve the desired composition without considering the director's ability to provide a variety of viewpoints limits the possibility of in-depth conversations and well-rounded decision-making. A board's membership should represent a range of expertise, experiences, backgrounds, and ways of thinking, as well as a suitable range of tenures considering the company's present and future conditions. It makes sense to conclude that a comprehensive slate of experiences and backgrounds, particularly those of directors who embody various societal perspectives, enhances board effectiveness and fosters the development of long-term shareholder value on corporate boards.
Young people nowadays have the most significant potential to influence global change. Entrepreneurs who co-founded businesses that later became the dominant force in the international corporate world, like Steve Jobs, Mark Zuckerberg, Bill Gates, Larry Page, and others, were all in their early 20s. Imagine if they had gone to a Fortune 500 corporation and requested to be appointed as directors on the board rather than launching their businesses. They might have received mockery. Younger people must represent businesses on their boards in this dynamic world.
Millennials are under-represented
The majority of people on the planet are under 30 years old. Given that millennials make up the largest generation in the workforce worldwide, young people account for a sizable share of the customer base. Since significant decisions are made on company boards, young people must serve on them. The numbers could be better, according to PwC data: of the 500 S&P businesses in the report, almost half do not have any directors who are 50 years of age or younger. For many of these big businesses, having a diverse workforce in terms of age might be revolutionary.
Shifting Power Structures in the Business Sector
The World Economic Forum reports millennials favour companies with greater environmental responsibility and ethics. Furthermore, millennials are frequently more tech-savvy and purpose-driven, which is essential when positioning brands and promoting items.
A company's primary decision-making body must include members representing this expanding market segment. A corporation must understand how consumers think and decide to position its brand accordingly. Adding younger members to the board can be quite beneficial, particularly regarding two important but unconnected issues: disgruntled younger employees and shifting market conditions.
Getting Ready for the Future
According to the World Economic Forum, 17% of newly appointed directors in S&P companies in 2018 were 50 or younger. Businesses sense that they need more tech-savvy directors to handle breakthroughs that have the potential to upend entire markets.
According to the PwC analysis, young people who join boards tend to bring fresh ideas and talents, and age diversity fosters a variety of viewpoints and methods within the organisation. According to McKinsey, 84% of executives say innovation is vital to growth strategy, and 80% believe their business models are at risk as the world grows more digital.
Innovation And Creativity Are Needed
The future lies not only in quick innovation but also in being aware of others' disruptive innovations because knowledge is becoming increasingly accessible and readily available.
The lifespan of companies is getting shorter. While experience is unquestionably essential, in the age of innovation, it might not be as helpful when making decisions in the future concerning issues we have yet to consider. Young people have an advantage over older generations because they are closer to the millennial generation and more tech-savvy. Business decisions in the future must be made with originality and emotional appeal in mind.
Young Directors in Action at Work
The PwC survey states that 95% of young directors are actively involved in their careers daily, which indicates that they better understand millennials' preferences. Young directors will be more equipped to bring knowledge from the ground up and stay in touch with an accelerated market, which may benefit organisations. They follow current market trends and are active on social media.
Millennials on Gucci's shadow board, established in 2015, met with senior executives regularly. During this time, Gucci's sales increased, and the CEO acknowledged that the shadow board's insights gave senior executives a wake-up call. Prada's sales declined during that same period, and the CEO claimed in 2017 that this was because the company took a while to recognise the significance of young, powerful bloggers and digital platforms.
A Younger Corporate Board in the Future
It is time for gifted individuals in their 40s or even 30s to be admitted to company boards. Senior directors will always have a role because of their accomplishments and experience. Still, younger individuals should also sit on the corporate board in a world where millennials make up most of the workforce, and consumer preferences are shifting in favour of younger generations.
The Benefits of Integrating Young Directors
Fresh Perspectives and Innovation
One of the most significant advantages of including younger directors on corporate boards is the infusion of fresh perspectives. Younger professionals often bring innovative ideas and approaches that can drive modernisation and enhance a company's competitive edge. Their familiarity with emerging technologies and trends enables them to offer insights that older board members may not fully grasp. For example, younger directors are more likely to understand the nuances of digital transformation, social media strategies, and consumer behaviour in the digital age.
Companies that embrace innovation are better positioned to adapt to market changes and seize new opportunities. By incorporating younger directors, boards can foster a culture of agility and forward-thinking, which is crucial for navigating the complexities of today's business environment.
Enhanced Understanding of Emerging Markets
The global marketplace is increasingly influenced by younger demographics, particularly in emerging markets. Millennials and Gen Z represent a significant portion of the global consumer base, and their preferences and behaviours shape market trends. Young directors, with their firsthand experience and understanding of these trends, can provide valuable insights into how companies can effectively engage with these growing markets.
For instance, younger directors can offer guidance on tailoring products and services to meet the needs of a digitally savvy and socially conscious audience. Their perspectives can help companies stay relevant and responsive to shifting consumer expectations.
Promoting Diversity and Inclusion
Diversity and inclusion have become central themes in modern corporate governance. Research has consistently shown that diverse boards contribute to better decision-making and improved business performance. Integrating younger directors is a crucial aspect of achieving a more diverse and inclusive board composition.
Age diversity, in particular, brings a range of experiences and viewpoints that enrich board discussions. Younger directors can complement the experience of older members by offering different angles on strategic issues and challenging traditional thinking. This diversity of thought can lead to more comprehensive and well-rounded decision-making.
Navigating Technological Advancements
The rapid pace of technological change presents both opportunities and challenges for businesses. Younger directors, who have grown up in a digital world, are more adept at understanding and leveraging new technologies. Their expertise can be instrumental in guiding boards through digital transformation efforts and ensuring that companies remain competitive in an increasingly tech-driven landscape.
Whether navigating cybersecurity threats, adopting new software solutions, or exploring innovative business models, younger directors can provide valuable guidance on how to integrate technology effectively into business strategies.
The Challenges of Integrating Young Directors
Generational Differences and Tensions
One of the primary challenges of integrating younger professionals into corporate boards is managing generational differences. Older board members may have different expectations, communication styles, and decision-making approaches compared to their younger counterparts. These differences can sometimes lead to friction and misunderstandings.
For example, younger directors may advocate for more agile and collaborative decision-making processes, while older members may prefer a more hierarchical and formal approach. Bridging these generational gaps requires open communication and a willingness to understand and respect different perspectives.
Balancing Experience and Innovation
While younger directors bring fresh perspectives, their lack of extensive industry experience can be a concern for some boards. Experience is often valued for its role in providing strategic insight and guiding decision-making. Integrating younger professionals must be balanced with maintaining the wisdom and strategic insight that comes with experience.
Boards need to find ways to leverage the strengths of both younger and older directors. This involves creating an environment where younger directors can contribute their innovative ideas while also benefiting from the mentorship and guidance of more experienced members.
Overcoming Resistance to Change
Established boards may face resistance when introducing younger directors, particularly if they strongly adhere to traditional governance practices. Some board members may view the integration of younger professionals as a threat to established norms and power dynamics.
Overcoming this resistance requires a strategic approach to change management. Boards should focus on the potential benefits of age diversity and create a culture that values and supports the contributions of all members, regardless of their age.
Ensuring Effective Onboarding and Integration
Successful integration of younger directors requires a well-structured onboarding process. New board members must know the company's culture, governance practices, and strategic priorities. Without proper onboarding, younger directors may struggle to effectively contribute to board discussions and decision-making.
Boards should invest in comprehensive onboarding programs that provide new directors with the knowledge and resources they need to succeed. Additionally, fostering a supportive environment that encourages collaboration and mutual respect can help facilitate smoother integration.
Best Practices for Integrating Young Directors
Develop Clear Onboarding Programmes
A well-designed onboarding program is essential for helping new directors understand their roles and responsibilities. This program should include an overview of the company's history, governance structure, strategic goals, and key issues facing the organisation. Providing younger directors with access to relevant documents, reports, and data can also help them get up to speed quickly.
Foster Open Communication
Encouraging open communication among board members is crucial for addressing generational differences and building a collaborative environment. Regularly scheduled meetings, workshops, and team-building activities can help bridge gaps and promote understanding between younger and older directors.
Promote Mentorship and Knowledge Sharing
Pairing younger directors with experienced mentors can facilitate knowledge transfer and help new members navigate the complexities of board responsibilities. Mentorship programs can provide younger directors with valuable insights and guidance while allowing experienced members to share their expertise.
Encourage Diverse Perspectives
Boards should actively seek out and value diverse perspectives in their discussions and decision-making processes. Encouraging younger directors to contribute their ideas and insights can lead to more innovative and effective solutions. All board members need to recognise the value of diverse viewpoints and work collaboratively to address challenges.
Regularly Evaluate Board Effectiveness
Periodic evaluations of board effectiveness can help identify areas for improvement and ensure that the board is functioning optimally. These evaluations should consider factors such as board composition, dynamics, and performance. By regularly assessing board effectiveness, organisations can make informed decisions about board composition and address any issues that may arise.
Conclusion
The integration of younger professionals into corporate boards represents a significant shift in corporate governance. While this transition presents challenges, it also offers numerous benefits, including fresh perspectives, enhanced innovation, and an improved understanding of emerging markets. By addressing generational differences, balancing experience with innovation, and implementing best practices for onboarding and integration, organisations can successfully incorporate younger directors into their boards.
Ultimately, the goal is to create a more dynamic and effective board that can navigate the complexities of the modern business environment. Embracing age diversity and leveraging the unique strengths of both younger and older directors can lead to better decision-making, increased competitiveness, and long-term success. As corporate governance continues to evolve, the role of young directors will become increasingly important in shaping the future of business.
Our Directors’ Institute- World Council of Directors can help you accelerate your board journey by training you on your roles and responsibilities to be carried out efficiently, helping you make a significant contribution to the board and raise corporate governance standards within the organization.
Comments